Favorite Idols

[Cael K.]

Aaaaah, sure. Even though the thread is a little old. Roughly in order...

SSS Tier: Azusa
SS Tier: Yumeko, Yukiho, Makoto, Eri
S Tier: Haruka, Ai, Ryou, Hibiki, Takane, Chihaya
A Tier: Yayoi, Ritsuko, Miki
Untiered: Ami & Mami, Iori

[nyachan]

since people revived this...

Love Tier
Ritsuko
Yukiho
Miki
Ami/Mami
Eri
Like Tier
Hibiki
Yayoi
Chihaya
Makoto
Okay Tier
Ai
Haruka
Iori
Takane
Dislike Tier
Azusa
Ryo

iunno why but I just can't stand producing Azusa after the first time. Her singing voice is nice but ugh I just can't stand producing her.

[y2j.kj]

Love tier
Iori
Miki
Ai
Eri
Like Tier
takane
Hibiki
Chihaya
Haruka
Yukiho
Azusa
Ami-Mami
Yayoi
Makoto
Dislike Tier
Ryo
Ritsuko

I think why people here love themselves  
Liking the producer means liking your self.
BECAUSE you play as the producer. meh~

this is not what people call narcissist?

[Elixir]

Love: Yayoi

Like: Chihaya, Miki, Takane, Azusa

Neutral: Haruka, Makoto, Hibiki, Mami (iM@S 2 only)

Dislike: Ritsuko, Ami, Mami (iM@S 1 only)

Favourite trios for L4U: Chihaya/Miki/Makoto (balanced), Yayoi/Miki/Iori (fast songs, ie. Kiramekirari/Watashi ha Aidoru), Azusa/Chihaya/Makoto (slow songs, ie. Me ga au Toki/Aoitori/etc)

Favourite trio for iM@S 1: Chihaya/Iori/Ritsuko (also the hardest to obtain S rank with, but I'm glad I managed to do so.)

[Cael K.]

So, since I've got nothing better to do this weekend, I decided to count votes.

Idol: Favorite or better / Like / Indifferent / Dislike or worse   Forgotten  (Total)  =  Average Rank

Code: [Select]

By given name, alphabetical English.

Ai:       4 /  8 /  9 / 2  7  (23)  =  2.39
Ami:      7 / 14 /  6 / 3  0  (30)  =  2.17
Azusa:    5 / 13 /  7 / 4  1  (29)  =  2.34
Chihaya:  8 / 14 /  4 / 4  0  (30)  =  2.13
Eri:      7 / 11 /  5 / 2  5  (25)  =  2.08
Haruka:   5 / 11 / 12 / 2  0  (30)  =  2.37
Hibiki:   6 / 14 /  6 / 3  1  (29)  =  2.21
Iori:     5 /  9 /  8 / 6  2  (28)  =  2.54
Makoto:   9 /  7 / 11 / 1  2  (28)  =  2.14
Mami:     8 / 11 /  7 / 2  2  (28)  =  2.11
Miki:    12 / 12 /  4 / 2  0  (30)  =  1.87
Ritsuko:  5 / 11 /  8 / 5  1  (29)  =  2.45
Ryou:     5 /  7 /  6 / 6  5  (25)  =  2.44
Takane:   8 / 13 /  4 / 3  2  (28)  =  2.07
Yayoi:    9 / 16 /  3 / 1  0  (30)  =  1.90
Yukiho:   9 / 15 /  3 / 2  1  (29)  =  2.03

Cineria:  0 /  1 /  0 / 0  29  (1)  =  2.00
DHaruka:  0 /  1 /  0 / 0  29  (1)  =  2.00
Kotori:   1 /  4 /  0 / 0  25  (5)  =  1.80
Yumeko:   1 /  1 /  0 / 3  25  (5)  =  3.00

Nonowa:   1 /  0 /  0 / 0  29  (1)  =  1.00
Puchis:   1 /  0 /  0 / 0  29  (1)  =  1.00


Code: [Select]

By average rank.

Miki:    12 / 12 /  4 / 2  0  (30)  =  1.87
Yayoi:    9 / 16 /  3 / 1  0  (30)  =  1.90
Yukiho:   9 / 15 /  3 / 2  1  (29)  =  2.03
Takane:   8 / 13 /  4 / 3  2  (28)  =  2.07
Eri:      7 / 11 /  5 / 2  5  (25)  =  2.08
Mami:     8 / 11 /  7 / 2  2  (28)  =  2.11
Chihaya:  8 / 14 /  4 / 4  0  (30)  =  2.13
Makoto:   9 /  7 / 11 / 1  2  (28)  =  2.14
Ami:      7 / 14 /  6 / 3  0  (30)  =  2.17
Hibiki:   6 / 14 /  6 / 3  1  (29)  =  2.21
Azusa:    5 / 13 /  7 / 4  1  (29)  =  2.34
Haruka:   5 / 11 / 12 / 2  0  (30)  =  2.37
Ai:       4 /  8 /  9 / 2  7  (23)  =  2.39
Ryou:     5 /  7 /  6 / 6  5  (25)  =  2.44
Ritsuko:  5 / 11 /  8 / 5  1  (29)  =  2.45
Iori:     5 /  9 /  8 / 6  2  (28)  =  2.54

Kotori:   1 /  4 /  0 / 0  25  (5)  =  1.80
Cineria:  0 /  1 /  0 / 0  29  (1)  =  2.00
DHaruka:  0 /  1 /  0 / 0  29  (1)  =  2.00
Yumeko:   1 /  1 /  0 / 3  25  (5)  =  3.00

Nonowa:   1 /  0 /  0 / 0  29  (1)  =  1.00
Puchis:   1 /  0 /  0 / 0  29  (1)  =  1.00


snip

... Yukiho?

[azuyuki]

...?
That... was pretty scientific, how long did it take you to do this?

[Cael K.]

Not too long, but counting votes took the most time.

Finding someone's average rank was just (number of votes for rank) x (rank number) + next rank + next rank... all divided by the total number of votes. So for Ai, who got a 4/8/9/2 spread from favorite to dislike, (4 x 1 + 8 x 2 + 9 x 3 + 2 x 4) / 23 = 2.39. Those went pretty fast with a calculator.

I also kinda did this because I wanted to know where everybody stood in terms of popularity. Polls anywhere seem to vary wildly depending on where you go, and I'm getting a general feel for where characters stand in relation to each other, but I didn't expect some of the things I saw here.

[Sev]

Not too long, but counting votes took the most time.

Finding someone's average rank was just (number of votes for rank) x (rank number) + next rank + next rank... all divided by the total number of votes. So for Ai, who got a 4/8/9/2 spread from favorite to dislike, (4 x 1 + 8 x 2 + 9 x 3 + 2 x 4) / 23 = 2.39. Those went pretty fast with a calculator.

I also kinda did this because I wanted to know where everybody stood in terms of popularity. Polls anywhere seem to vary wildly depending on where you go, and I'm getting a general feel for where characters stand in relation to each other, but I didn't expect some of the things I saw here.

We've got a fav idol poll here. only no ones voted in a while. Its in the Characters section

[Cael K.]

We've got a fav idol poll here. only no ones voted in a while. Its in the Characters section

Well look at that. Buried like a timid Yukiho...

I saw this topic on page one, so I figured that's all there was.

[Mind M@ster]

Waifu tier
Hibiki
Miki
Yukiho
Haruka
Chihaya
I would marry any of these girls in an instant, plus my indecisiveness is winning today.
Like tier
Ami and Mami
Yayoi
Eri
Iori
Makoto
Ai
Indifferent tier
Azusa
Ryo
Ritsuko
Takane

[altuixde]

Really Like tier
Chihaya
Haruka
Miki
Like tier
Iori
Ritsuko
Takane
Yukiho
Indifferent tier
Ami
Azusa
Hibiki
Makoto
Mami
Yayoi

Yukiho would be in my Really Like tier, except they changed her voice actress (I'm still getting used to Azumi Asakura).  Also, even the idols in my Indifferent tier have their good qualities.

[blake307]

I know I posted here a couple years back but here is my current list up to date.

Love Tier
Yukiho

Like Tier
Takane
Haruka
Chihaya
Miki
Azusa
Indifferent Tier
Hibiki
Iori
Mami
Ami
Makoto
Don't care about tier
Ritsuko
Yayoi

I don't dislike Ritsuko or Yayoi, i'm just not a fan of them that's all.

[TweenDoriru]

ooh, re-doing mine (not that so much has changed, but it's worth updating)

Super-Exclusive Tier:
Ami & Mami (honestly, I like them about the same. I prefer the Ami-hair on Mami, though)
Haruka
Ritsuko
Makoto

Like Tier:
Hibiki
Azusa
Yukiho (Yurishii's and Azumin's)
Iori
Yayoi
Ai
Gyaoooooon (mostly indifferent. I just like that sound)

Indifferent:
Chihaya
Miki (depends, really)
Takane
Eri

I really can't say I actually dislike any of the idols at this point. ♥

[animagic4u]

I don't think I ever did mine so here goes nothing:

Waifu-
Harurun

Love-
Mikimiki
Yayoi
Azusa
Chihaya
Iori

Like-
Ami/Mami
Makoto
Ricchan

Don't Care-
Takane
Yukiho
Hibiki

[Logan]

Majorly updating mine! My old one was hateful and my opinion has changed quite a bit!

~Kami oshi~
Mami / Ami (I prefer Mami but love both <3)

~Oshimen~
Miki
Yukiho
Takane
Ai
Yayoi

~Meh~
Hibiki
Haruka
Ritsuko
Chihaya
Iori
Eri

~Ehh~
Azusa
Jupiter

~Don't Care About At All~
Makoto (sorry u gaiz ;___;)
Ryo