THE iDOLM@STER > Characters

765 Singing Test

(1/2) > >>

SideM:
I know there's already a couple topics asking who your favorite singer is, but this is a little different. I decided to throw in some numbers because who doesn't like math ::) to see who I thought was the best singer. I tried to be as unbiased as possible, but I'm not sure how well I did, so you guys should tell me what you think!

The way I did it was I picked 10 songs that I felt were challenging to sing and covered a variety of styles. Then I rated each idol's version of a song out of 10 and added up the scores to get an overall percentage score.

The songs I chose were

* Marionette no Kokoro
* Vault That Borderline!
* Futari no Kioku
* Tonari ni...
* Kiramekirari
* Honey Heartbeat
* 99 Nights
* Here we go!!
* First Stage
* Kimi*ChannelSome other songs I considered were Overmaster, Kyun! Vampire Girl, and Watashi-tachi wa Zutto...Deshou?

Their final scores were

* Takane
* Hibiki
* Chihaya
* Azusa
* Miki
* Yukiho
* Makoto
* Mami and Ami
* Iori
* Ritsuko
* Haruka
* YayoiIf you think there was a better way I could have graded this or better songs to use, tell me! I'd like to see what you think. I can also post their individual scores if anybody wants.

Virgofall:
I WANT to say that this is a good idea, but even without bias there's one glaring problem here - Yukiho, because of her VA switch. Here we go and First Stage never received Asakura solos, and most of the other listed songs you judged from only have solo opportunities from one VA or the other (and I'm aware that there are solo parts of group songs you could judge from, but that muddies your goal).

Okayu:
I'm too biased to ever join in a thread like this.

ChocoCats:
Not sure what I feel about this as I'm not a fan of these bias-type threads, especially this one. Opinions are nice, but with the way it's written... not so much. I think you better off removing the scores and just tell it in words. Let's hope that this doesn't turn into a flame war, but that shouldn't be a problem considering our records here. I don't want to deal with... certain people here.

DeviantProtagonist:

--- Quote from: Okayu on March 30, 2015, 01:04:53 am ---I'm too biased to ever join in a thread like this.
--- End quote ---

Probably this. What I will say for certain is that the likes of Hibiki has phenomenal range of voice -- from cutesy to mellow then furor, she has it down pat.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page