THE iDOLM@STER > Derived products, CD albums & anime
The iDOLM@STER Cinderella Girls Anime Discussion
Vas:
Now, I ain't speaking for all MAL users, but generally a lot of their reactions and thoughts on niche anime (such as iM@S) are typically misled due to a lack of understanding of source material. That, and typically askew. I tend to stay away from there ;P But seriously though, I think that guy's missing a point. Sure, 346 is a big production company, but the specific girls in the Cinderella Project aren't exactly "there" yet in the anime. And the argument that there hasn't been a major conflict yet either is kinda off seeing as how things didn't start getting "conflicting" in the 2011 anime until around the half-way point (which is where we're at)
Edit:Ninja'd lol. But yeah, that second quote you posted. It hits home indeed. Yes, I love iM@S myself more than most other things as well, and was excited to hear about the CG anime too, but while I'm loving it so far, it's just not the same...Still great imo, but again, not the same.
Nayre:
HNNNNGGG Rin, why you do this to me... Aww Ranko, you little cutie... and Min--Mami?! W-What are you doing here?! :o
MetalPredat0r:
I feel like the only one who doesn't mind when a main cast completely changes as long as the new cast can fit well with the original cast.
I guess this hasn't hit me as hard because I knew for a long time that Cinderella Girls was gonna get an anime and I knew about these characters beforehand thanks to multiple hours of research. (No life. XP!) But I can definitely see where some people are coming from. Some people are only in it for the anime and plenty of people knew nothing about CG until this anime aired.
--- Quote from: Nayre on June 23, 2015, 02:20:06 am ---HNNNNGGG Rin, why you do this to me... Aww Ranko, you little cutie... and Min--Mami?! W-What are you doing here?! :o
--- End quote ---
Minami..... Mami.... Oh god, I never caught that! XD!
(If you don't get it, remove the "in" from Minami's name.)
Maka:
I don't even bother with MAL reviews, even if I'm obsessed with the series. :/ There's so much... Negativity.
also a lot of people forget that Mio is a typical teenager... She's gonna be a little overemotional. If you've ever talked to a 15 year old girl, it's not a completely rational time. But then again I've been a teenage girl before and most people on this thread or on MAL in the IM@S fandom haven't lol
MetalPredat0r:
--- Quote from: Maka on June 23, 2015, 02:27:58 am ---I don't even bother with MAL reviews, even if I'm obsessed with the series. :/ There's so much... Negativity.
--- End quote ---
I stopped with MAL after Hyperdimension Neptunia: The Animation and ESPECIALLY BlazBlue: Alter Memory. I will admit the latter was legitimately terrible, but holy crap sometimes it seemed like they were REALLY trying too hard to find flaws that it ended up being nitpicking and dodging the things that are actually wrong with it. (Talking about how Tsubaki shouldn't be bribing a man when the real issue is that nothing is ever explained!)
It doesn't surprise me that it's probably full of a ton of people that have little to no idea what iM@S is. I get that any anime can be someone's first, but still.
But then again, can't really trust a place that's abbreviated with the same spelling as the Spanish word for "bad". ::)
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version