THE iDOLM@STER > Other iM@S games
Idolmaster Cinderella Girls
Maka:
I love CG's art. It's been really strong and pretty from the beginning. Even the blander cards are pretty.
There's only one card that I would really say is wonky art-wise.
What's wrong with her face.......???
Although in the end I think I like ML's art better. It might not be as pretty and sometimes it's really weird (sexy golf? really???), but the amount of improvement is impressive.
(SUPER early card)
(Most recent Ami card)
I also think ML does more dynamic poses and interesting card ideas (instead of maid gacha, sports gacha, pool gacha, etc.). Like, AWESOME MECHA GIRLS!? How cool is that? Also the fun things in the background make me lol.
But in the end I still love both their art. I want all of Anastasia's SRs, they're all gorgeous ;_;
Steve:
Wow that looks nothing like Ami that I have in cinderella xD
And yeah this one Miria card seemed a bit off to me as well, they overdid it with the mouth size I think xD
I must say though, I am not a big fan of Mecha in general and always prefer swimsuit or sport clothes or cute and pretty dresses and such.
Also I feel like the mecha ami card is missing some "spark" in the face part, like it looks so plain as if it was a screencap from anime or something, no shading or lighting, compared to the sparkly shiny eyes and face of the cinderella art.
But it might just be this one card is supposed to be in that style, haven't seen any others.
Most likely just preference though, I am just too much into the moe pyon pyon kawaii type of artstyle xD
MetalPredat0r:
--- Quote from: Steve on May 13, 2015, 07:22:51 pm ---Also I feel like the mecha ami card is missing some "spark" in the face part, like it looks so plain as if it was a screencap from anime or something, no shading or lighting, compared to the sparkly shiny eyes and face of the cinderella art.
But it might just be this one card is supposed to be in that style, haven't seen any others.
Most likely just preference though, I am just too much into the moe pyon pyon kawaii type of artstyle xD
--- End quote ---
It mainly has to do with the fact that, in the context of that situation, Ami was possessed by an evil force, hence why she looks lifeless.
Imo, while Cinderella Girls' art style is cleaner, Million Live's os more dynamic and I prefer the latter due to that. Although, CG's is still good. Is it done by Dofuu, though?
ChocoCats:
--- Quote from: MetalPredat0r on May 13, 2015, 07:40:58 pm ---Imo, while Cinderella Girls' art style is cleaner, Million Live's is more dynamic and I prefer the latter due to that. Although, CG's is still good. Is it done by Dofuu, though?
--- End quote ---
It's done with Dofuu's style. It's just that Dofuu's the leading design. I'm still not much a fan of ML's artwork and that won't change. Variety's nice, but they still looked ridiculous in execution. Of course, CG's had its 'argh' moments (Airi's latest SR+ card and most of her cards, Miria's card shown above, etc).
Maka:
I like both moe moe pyon and the more dynamic cards too, so getting the chance to play both is a win-win B] My favorite card set so far in CG is probably the Secret Night Party gacha. The cards are gorgeous! Plus I like purple.
http://346production.tumblr.com/post/112317615942/secret-night-party-gacha-2015-02-28-2015-03-09
Other ones I like...
http://346production.tumblr.com/post/96264106637
http://346production.tumblr.com/post/56972785154
http://346production.tumblr.com/post/51950463612
(I have waaaaaay more rare cards in ML though. The fact that ML takes PayPal is both a blessing and a curse.)
Dofuu did the original designs but I think each idol has a specific artist? That's why different idols have different art styles. You can see it a lot in Yuko, Michiru, Kanade, Anya, and Kozue. For example, Anya's hair is a lot more detailed than other idols'.
I remember reading that it's a team of people doing the cards, but don't quote me on this because I'm going 100% off of memory.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version