THE iDOLM@STER > Other iM@S games
Idolmaster Cinderella Girls
Eab1990:
Yeah, Syoko's interview literally scared the shit out of me. Should not have been listening to it at work.
Nao had a great interview with Producer (and not Staff-san, surprisingly) teasing her every step of the way.
Karen, wasn't crazy about. Was amusing whenever her mom interrupted them though.
Yuko had a lot of Nana vibes to her interview.
Sae's was long as hell, but her voice is hnnnnnnng, so it's all good. Her song's surprisingly catchy too.
Would probably rank Sae > Nao > Syoko/Yuko > Karen overall.
Nargrakhan:
--- Quote from: Eab1990 on May 02, 2014, 11:31:36 pm ---Yuko had a lot of Nana vibes to her interview.
--- End quote ---
I think part of it is because they recycled a music track that was first featured in Nana's drama skit. Another factor is how she was repeatedly called out for her ESP feats, just how Nana gets constantly called out for her alien claims.
To be honest, I didn't like her drama skit at all. It didn't add anything new to what we know about her... she still just a chuunibyo... and Ranko is the queen of that gimmick. The song was okay, but just average at best.
--- Quote from: Eab1990 on May 02, 2014, 11:31:36 pm ---Sae's was long as hell, but her voice is hnnnnnnng, so it's all good. Her song's surprisingly catchy too.
--- End quote ---
Yea. Her way of speaking goes above and beyond what I was expecting. Producer~han is so lucky to have her attention. I agree about her song: the massive use of Japanese instruments and quasi-traditional singing really made it work.
--- Quote from: Eab1990 on May 02, 2014, 11:31:36 pm ---Would probably rank Sae > Nao > Syoko/Yuko > Karen overall.
--- End quote ---
I haven't heard Nao or Karen yet (they're due to arrive on Monday with the second shipment), but so far I'd rate them as:
Syoko > Sae >>> Yuko
I ended up being slightly unhappy with Syoko's song (the melody just doesn't vibe with me for some reason), but her drama skit was purest win. Sae is a close second (great song and awesome voice). Yuko is a waaaaaay distant third for me. I feel they could have done a lot better with her. There was no meat to her personality. As she is, I'd even place her at the bottom of my likes for the idols who've had Cinderella Master CD's so far.
Eab1990:
I'm easy to amuse and I wasn't expecting much out of Yuko, so what I got, I was okay with. Sure, Nana has the crazier song, while Yuko's chuunibyou interview isn't quite as farfetched. Still a far cry from Ranko or whoever else, but yeah. I guess overall, she's middle-ground, which makes me rank her the same as Syoko, simply because Syoko went entirely the other direction and somehow ended up being TOO crazy for me.
Nao's is just so full of trolling. Feels like the creators had fun with that.
On the other hand, Karen was a bit too mellow, and didn't have the benefit of having Sae's amazing voice. It's kinda telling when her voiceless mom is more entertaining than the idol herself.
SakuraMaxX:
Oh man I wish I could get a translation of Karen's drama track now. I always imagined she'd have helicopter parents so I'm kinda curious now.
Nargrakhan:
--- Quote from: Eab1990 on May 03, 2014, 05:40:05 am ---...simply because Syoko went entirely the other direction and somehow ended up being TOO crazy for me.
--- End quote ---
Aye. She's a total psychopath. However it also made me feel sorry for her too... she's been socially isolated for so long, it drove her to create imaginary friends for sanity. It also puts more context into her "let the world burn" crazy mode: it seems to be a mental barrier that keeps her ordinary personality from realizing how unfair life can be. She's only 15 years old and that messed up. Really makes her obsession with the Producer being the first real friend, and catalyst for having more friends, very interesting. While Syoko isn't yandere, if she was betrayed or abandoned by the Producer, I wouldn't be surprised if her reaction could put Mayu's to shame. Syoko is completely unhinged.
But this is iM@S, and the Broducer would never do that. 8)
I also found how she constantly giggles quite neat. Makes it hard to tell if she's going to stay normal, or switch into GO TO HELL mode.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version